The Commentary Tradition in the Medieval West

Instructor: Theresa Gross-Diaz
Fridays, 2 pm-5pm, September 28- December 7, 2007


Course Description
Medieval thinkers wrote commentaries on nearly every imaginable genre of text, from law codes and Scripture to prophecies and contemporary fiction. Commentaries - explanations and interpretations of important texts - have drawn increasing attention from medievalists as sources for understanding the ways medieval people studied, taught, expressed complex and original ideas, and organized information.  Yet many students of the Middle Ages rarely or never encounter this form of writing or think about it critically while in graduate school.   This course will be an interdisciplinary introduction to the wide range of commentary literature, and a survey of recent trends and approaches in utilizing commentaries in various fields.   We will both address the secondary literature and tackle some commentaries directly.  While most of the commentaries we will look at were written in Latin, a few are in vernaculars, and we will even investigate images as commentary*.  The aim is to introduce students to the wonderful potential of commentaries and the creative ways they can be used to better understand the Middle Ages. 

The Newberry is particularly well equipped to support such a course.  Not only are hard-to-find secondary sources and editions present in the Library (such as Aurora: Petri Rigae Biblia versificata: A Verse Commentary on the Bible,  Notre Dame 1965), but manuscripts and incunables that comprise commentary in varying forms will allow students to work with the well-known (e.g. Aquinas' commentary on the Sentences, MS 67.3) and the less familiar (e.g. Haly ibn Ridwan on [Ps-] Ptolemy, MS Ayer 744) in their original medieval formats.  Students will have at least one exercise based on a choice of manuscript or incunable from the collection.  The instructor, who has previously taught at the Newberry,  has published on various medieval Psalms commentaries and is currently writing a book on the subject.

 *(In most cases the commentaries studied in class will be available in English or other modern language translation; however, some knowledge of Latin will be useful.)